Ethereum Privacy Technology Comparison: FHE and MPC solution
On November 20, on-chain data showed that an address deposited another 5,000 ETH to Binance after nine days, bringing its total deposits to 6,077 ETH. On the same day, EthSystems published a comparative report on five types of Ethereum privacy technology, noting that FHE and MPC only conceal transaction amounts, while privacy pools, privacy L2s, and TEEs can conceal the identities of transacting parties but face liquidity, security, or hardware trust risks.
Event Timeline
- [11-20 03:49] An address deposited another 5,000 ETH to Binance, bringing its total deposits since November 10 to 6,077 ETH (Odaily Planet Daily)
- [11-20 13:08] EthSystems compares five types of Ethereum privacy technology: common FHE and MPC solutions still disclose the addresses of both parties to a transaction (Wu Says)
Background and Impact
On November 20, on-chain analyst Ai Yi observed that an address deposited another 5,000 ETH to Binance after an interval of nine days, at an average deposit price of $1,790.11. Since November 10, the address has deposited a total of 6,077 ETH, worth $10.878 million; if it chooses to sell, it is estimated to incur a loss of $2.834 million. The address withdrew a total of 17,077.46 ETH between November 1 and 10. It currently holds about 11,000 ETH, with an unrealized loss of $5.605 million.
On the same day, EthSystems, a company developing Ethereum privacy infrastructure, published a research article systematically comparing five major types of privacy technology on Ethereum: Shielded Pools, privacy Layer 2, fully homomorphic encryption (FHE), trusted execution environments (TEE), and multiparty computation (MPC). The research noted that under common architectures, FHE and MPC solutions can conceal transaction amounts, but the addresses of both parties to a transaction usually remain public. By contrast, privacy pools, privacy Layer 2, and TEE can conceal the identities of the parties to a transaction. However, these three types of solutions face challenges including insufficient pool liquidity, cross-chain bridge security risks, and excessive reliance on hardware trust, respectively.
EthSystems emphasized that in compliant use cases, such as tokenized deposits issued by banks, technology choices must meet requirements for regulators to review transaction records, freeze specific accounts, and verify asset balances. The company recommended that financial institutions evaluate and select suitable privacy technology solutions based on factors such as actual transaction volume, compliance requirements, degree of third-party dependence, and operating costs, rather than relying on a single technological approach.
Frequently Asked Questions
### What information can FHE and MPC solutions conceal in private Ethereum transactions?
FHE and MPC solutions can conceal transaction amounts, but the addresses of both parties to a transaction remain public. To conceal the identities of the transacting parties, privacy pools, privacy Layer 2, or TEE solutions are needed, but these entail corresponding liquidity, security, or hardware trust risks.
### What are the main risks of privacy pools, privacy Layer 2, and TEE solutions?
Privacy pools face the risk of insufficient liquidity. Privacy Layer 2 relies on cross-chain bridges and therefore carries security risks. TEE solutions depend on a hardware trust foundation and may involve centralized trust issues.
### How can users trade Ethereum through mainstream exchange apps?
Users can trade ETH on platforms such as Binance (register and download the Binance app), Gate.io (register and download the Gate.io app), HTX (register and download the HTX app), Bitget (register and download the Bitget app), or OKX (register and download the OKX app). However, they should note that platforms differ in their support for privacy transactions and their compliance requirements.